Chemical etching vs. stamping & laser

The benefits of chemical etching

Process comparison table


Photo etchingLaser cuttingStampingWire EDMWater jetElectroforming
SamplingLow costLow costHigh costLow costLow costMedium cost
MetalsNearly all metalsNearly all metalsNearly all metalsConductive metalsNearly all metalsNickel and copper
HardnessNo restrictionNo restrictionProblems with soft, hard or brittle metalsHardness is a considerationHardness is a considerationTypically 200-670 HV
StressNo stressThermal stress on cutting edgeStress at cutting edgeDeformation, tempering and structural changes may occurLimited stress on cutting edgeLow-stress
BurrsNo burringMicro burringPartial burringMicro burringMicro burringNo burring
Tooling and design changesQuick, easy and cost effectiveQuick, easy and cost effectiveExpensive and time consumingQuick, easy and cost-effectiveQuick, easy and cost- effectiveQuick, easy and cost-effective
Typical lead timesSeven daysSeven daysSix weeks - six monthsSeven daysSeven daysSeven days
Tolerance as a percentage of metal thickness±10%±5%±10%±10%±15%±5%
Can parts be supplied in sheets for easy counting/handling?YesYesNot easilyYesYesYes